BY DANIEL G. SOL0RZANO
The California educational system is letting
gifted Latina students fall through the cracks. Given the size
and continuing growth of this population, the schools are also
undermining the future viability of our state’s economy
and social infrastructure.
Today, Latinas account for half of all female
children entering public education, but they will also experience
a dropout rate three times higher than their white peers. Thus,
by the time they reach college age, Latina students constitute
only 9% of undergraduates in the University of California system.
In a study that I co-authored with four Latina
education students, we discovered that Latina high school students
have limited access to the academic enhancement programs that
will increase their likelihood of college admission. Though
Latinas constitute 43% of girls enrolled in California public
schools, they represent only 21% of the girls enrolled in Gifted
and Talented Education programs (GATE). Conversely, white females
make up 36% of the female student population and 52% of all
girls in GATE.
What makes these disparities even more problematic
is that current procedures used to identify “gifted”
students are at the discretion of school districts, schools
and teachers. There is little to no state oversight of the student
eligibility standards or of the procedures for evaluating student
success in the program. Such a situation raises more questions
than it provides answers, since there are no safeguards in place
to ensure equity, fairness and consistency for access to these
important educational programs.
Educators like to talk about the educational
pipeline. But in California there are actually two pipelines,
separate and unequal, producing shocking disparities between
the Latino and non-Latino populations. For Latinas, the route
is filled with leakages and blockages. Latina students often
face a lack of qualified teachers and adequate instructional
materials, find themselves tracked into remedial instruction,
and experience significant school segregation in underfunded
schools.
Latinas are in a painful Catch-22. First, they
are denied access to academic enhancement programs, and now
university outreach efforts are expected to be cut by 50% next
year. In short, Latinas are being “gated out” of
receiving the same educational opportunities as their white
peers. Outreach to underrepresented populations cannot remain
at the margin of UC’s mission.
The American Civil Liberties Union, as part
of its Latina Rights Project, originally commissioned our study.
In the end, the courts might offer the only viable option unless
educators and legislators are willing to examine the policies
and other factors that produce such stark educational inequities.
In 2002, Latina/o students were 14% of those
admitted to UCLA. While these numbers have increased ever so
slightly over the last five years, they are not in proportion
to the dramatic growth of the Latina/o K-12 population in California.
By 2008, Latinas and Latinos will become the majority of the
California K-12 student population. But how many will have been
given an education that prepares them to go on to college? The
future of our state will be determined by the answer to that
question.
Solorzano is professor and chair of
the Department of Education and the Faculty Advisory Committee
of the Chicano Studies Research Center. His policy brief can
be obtained from aztlan@csrc.ucla.edu.